I just got the news that the two American hikers imprisoned in Iran for two years have been released.
It’s been an article of faith in some quarters that the hikers had it coming — that they had no earthly reason for hiking near the Iranian border and, by implication, got what they deserved.
This is, for want of a better word, bullshit. Iran held them hostage because Iran likes to do that to Americans. The espionage charges were crap and everybody knew it.
Accounts of the hikers’ arrest go like this: they were hiking a trail when an Iranian soldier waved them across the Iranian border. They complied because you never know what happens when somebody with a rifle is waving at you. Best to do as directed.
Once they were across the border, they were arrested for illegally entering Iran — which never would have happened if an armed Iranian hadn’t given them, essentially, no sane alternative.
And then they became pawns in some deranged Iranian power game.
Iran was in the wrong here, morally, ethically, politically. Saying the hikers should never have been there is the same as saying a woman shouldn’t wear a short skirt if she expects to avoid being raped.
Iran has behaved criminally. Most likely it took the regime two years to find a way to extricate themselves from the mess this case created. The hikers should’ve been home in two days.
I won’t deny the hikers showed questionable judgment. But that does not absolve Iran for exploiting it.
All the people raving about how stupid it was to hike near the Iranian border are basically saying Iranians are no better than grizzly bears: stay away if you don’t want to get eaten.
This, too, is BS. The citizens of Iran are people who know right from wrong. Persian civilization has thrived for thousands of years. They had a choice to make — letting the hikers go because it was the right thing to do, or creating a crisis to serve somebody’s political ends.
Guess I’ll never understand this idiotic urge to let criminals off the hook.
It’s about time someone said it! And said it well!
Questionable judgment is an understatement….there was NO GOOD REASON to be that close to that border other than stupidity!
See, this is the misconception people have about this incident: they were hiking near a popular waterfall that lots of people hike to. Granted they could have just turned around and went back where they came from.
But hikers explore. It happens. They strayed closer to the border, but it was not like they could run away when some soldier with an AK-47 was yelling at them.
Basic common sense is you obey the guy with the rifle and hope this discourages him from killing you.
Besides the border was unmarked. It wasn’t like they climbed a fence or deliberately trespassed.
They weren’t smuggling drugs or doing anything creating a reasonable expectation of being locked up for two years.
This was not a ‘normal border region’ and with a regime like they have in Iran…..it is just makes no sense to get close. I in no way absolving Iran of wrong doing but one would think that picking a hike that close was not the thing to do.
But here’s my point: “they never should have been there” has been demonstrated without dispute, given what happened. It’s like crying over spilled milk.
What matters is how you clean up the mess.
And once you adopt the “never should’ve been there” line you’re basically saying “they got what they deserved.” That’s where I call BS.
No way is two years in prison a justifiable response to accidentally crossing an invisible border.
These people put themselves in harms way, pure and simple. No different than someone foolishly going into the back country unprepared and getting into trouble. There was never any question about what Iran would do given the chance. This isn’t the first time they’ve done it. If you’re going to walk the edge of a cliff, you need to be prepared for the consequences if you fall over. Victims are people who have no choice, that’s not the case here.
Well I don’t imagine anything I say can get through to you if you’ve created a definition of “victim” which basically says that the only way it’s a victim is if it’s a newborn baby ripped from his mother’s arms.
Everybody plays a role in their misfortune. Nobody has suggested it was an act of genius or bravery to go farting around in that area of the world.
But which is worse, stupidly bumbling across an invisible border or throwing somebody in prison for it for two years?
It’s like life without parole for a speeding ticket.
And if you take this “well it was their own damn fault” you absolve Iran of all responsibility for making a mountain out of this molehill. So the Iranians are robots, or animals, or somehow otherwise incapable of acting like normal human beings? I refuse to believe that.
Thank you, thank you, thank you! A morning talk show angered me so much because they were like “hike at home, the Rockies are nice…blah blah blah”.