WTA Blog highlights some of the damage done.
Those of us who’ve tried to hike on ATV trails rarely repeat the experience. Even when used legally and responsibly, the machines are noisy, polluting and leave behind huge, muddy ruts in trails. I once attempted to hike the old Naches Wagon trail over Naches Pass northeast of Mount Rainier, and found myself in a mud pit–where the constant buzzing noise wasn’t from mosquitoes. ATV trails are rarely “shared” trails, and result in the de facto exclusion of hikers from areas of our mountains.
My brother had a four-wheeler that he ruined by taking up a too-steep trail and rolling it end-over-end back down the hill. He got lucky, just some cuts and scrapes. Four-wheelers remind me of the oft-cited study which says that cyclists who wear helmets actually take on more risks that outweigh the benefit of the helmet. Or, U.S. football players suffering far worse injuries since the advent of helmets, face masks and pads encouraged them to hit each other much harder. (Mind you only a fool would ride a bike or play football these days without said “protection.”)
Intuitively a four-wheeler seems safe compared to vehicles with fewer wheels — until a crash, when its bulk makes it inherently unsafe. The illusion of safety lasts until it’s too late to correct it.
I sorta wish everybody would get over the testosterone rush of going fast through the woods. It’s not good for the woods and it’s not much good for the riders, either. As I’ve said many times, even walking at a couple miles per hour is too fast to really become “of” the wilds vs. passing through them. When you stop to take pictures you miss everything that isn’t in the frame. Still, at a walking pace you absorb a lot more nature than you ever will on wheels.
Just one tiny point about your comment – “…everybody would get over the testosterone rush…”
I no longer own an ATV, but when I had one, a “testosterone rush” was the last thing on my mind. Sure, a lot of ATV riders are testosterone driven, but there are many of us who simply enjoy getting to point A at a different speed than walking… or maybe we’ve only got a short weekend and would like to get to lake X.
That would be like painting all hikers with the “i’m a hippy peacenik” brush. 😉
I find it especially ironic when hiking on the cusp of a Sierra wilderness, within the National Forest access to the wilderness, and several hunters come flying past. I’ve yet to see one with a deer, though, but I’ve got to confess it makes me wonder. I travel so slowly in my 4 – wheeler I see EVERYTHING. It’s almost irresistably funny (if it weren’t so discincerting) that these folks blast past me on their ATV’s in order to kill something, and laud themselves as “outdoorsmen”. Yowza!
California actually has some decent regulations preventing motorized vehicles in the wilderness, so this tends to be less of an issue here.
My main beef is pack horses and cattle grazing. Both of those can have massive impact on the trail where they are allowed.
> I’ve yet to see one with a deer, though, but I’ve got to confess it makes me wonder.
I’ve seen hunters dragging deer back on a number of occasions. Hiking during that first week of hunting season is always a bit disconcerting, tho.
Good comments, all! Bottom line – there is NO PLACE IN NATURE for motorized – and some would say mechanized – traffic period. But we live in this temporizing age of compromise, of equal and shared use values, of everyone’s right, even special interest groups, to use trails and enjoy nature. Hence, motorboats and jet skis, snowmobiles, and ATVs. I agree with Mang – get over the testosterone rush and put your legs and lungs to good use!
I have some bad news for you… walking on an ATV trail isn’t the brightest place you could walk.
Perhaps a small dose of common sense is in order here, along with a bit of humility and reality as well if you think I have no right to ride my ATV in nature.