I keep promising not to write any more about bodily functions and keep breaking that promise but I have to figure, heck, everybody’s got to go, right?
So anyway: The last overnight trip I went on passed a popular lake about a mile from the trailhead. Must’ve been a dozen groups of campers, if not more, but there were no porta-potties or any other means of keeping all the crap in a central location. The area stank to high heaven from people not properly burying their poop, but here’s the thing: the lake is surrounded by rocky hills that don’t exactly abound with soft soil in which to dig a proper cat hole. Even if they wanted to be perfectly environmentally correct, the environment didn’t yield many options for making it happen.
Awhile after that campout I learned about this web site for RESTOP products, which provide resealable plastic bags that contain a chemical that breaks down and deodorizes human waste. Another well-known company sells WAG bags that do the same thing. Once your feces are in the bag and sealed, they can be tossed in any legal trash receptacle.
For sure there’s an ick factor to toting your droppings back to the trailhead but if you can get past that, the bag kits solve the most basic riddle confronting any backpacker: where do I go when The Urge hits? The kits are a bit more expensive that the natural method, but it’s a small price to pay for keeping the outdoors from smelling like an outhouse.
It is possible to take things too far.
At the risk of extending this lovely discussion… defecation is not an unnatural thing and carrying out the poop is overdoing it in all but exceptional situations. (You are required to carry it out if you climb the popular routes on Mt. Shasta for example -makes sense for a lot of reasons, including the fact that otherwise you would be dumping into the snow that you and others melt for water…)
In most cases, the real key is taking care to find an appropriate spot away from campsites and water sources and to then take care to use proper disposal techniques. I’ll spare you the details – they are available in lots of books, etc. But don’t be afraid to “take a hike” – sometimes a fairly long hike – away from your campsite.
And don’t forget to look for a spot with a view… 🙂
My personal experince with WAG bags on Mt. Whitney was good. As Dan mentioned, a spot with a view away from others is key here. Also follow the directions for closing up the bag to keep it from getting smelly.
Every backpakers should in MOST case pack out there smelly poop and toilet paper. It’s a simple respect for nature and others,since more and more poeple are
enjoying backcountry traveling. It’s not over doing it, it’s doing it right.